Matthew Berk • April 05, 2021
Anyone who's strolled through the coffee section of a Whole Foods or other higher-end supermarket has been exposed to the language of what we call “industrial coffee marketing." Terms like “organic," “shade grown," and “fair trade” are product descriptors meant to make us feel better about what we’re buying. But what do they actually mean?
Read on to understand the differences between fair trade and direct trade coffee.
The fair trade coffee movement is a complex knot of trading practices, social philosophies, labeling organizations, marketing tactics, and certification standards that seek to promote greater “equity” (fairness) in international trade of commodities such as coffee. These practices are generally applicable to developing countries, with an emphasis on the idea of sustainability.
In the coffee industry at large, fair trade standards are developed primarily by a cluster of four international trade networks, with certification determined by an entirely separate group. In the U.S. specifically, a company called Fair Trade USA is the dominant certifier of “fair trade” coffee, and sellers of coffee can pay them for the right to label their products as fair trade, assuming the standards (cost of labor, sustainable practices, minimum pricing, and the like) have been met for that particular coffee.
The strength of the label, we believe, can be boiled down to the mental image we as consumers paint when we see a fair trade label; we pay a little extra as an individual purchaser, and our belief is that this is reflected in better economic treatment of everyone in the supply chain, all the way down to the farmer who tilled the soil. Of course, the truth is infinitely more complex.
For example, critics argue that in some cases, exporters may be guaranteed a “fair” price, but neither the farms they represent nor their laborers necessarily benefit. Other critics point out that the economic benefits inherent in the idea of fair trade are largely dissipated through the intricate supply chain of commodity coffee trade, with large corporations seeing the bulk of the advantage. Still, others see fair trade as a marketing practice whose economic focus may or may not have any relevant impact on the actual growers of the coffee.
In short, fair trade coffee practices are backstopped by a paid certification program, and are generally intended to bolster the price of a roasted coffee at market by playing on our guilt over the state of agricultural economics throughout the world. That sounds negative, but if you really want your choice of coffee to help farmers directly, look instead for roasters who have direct trade relationships with farmers.
In the world of small-batch, specialty coffee, the emphasis is on practicing what’s known as “direct trade." What this means is that roasters regularly visit with and establish long-term, direct trading partnerships with the actual farmers from whom they source coffee. There may be other parties involved with the export, transport, storage or other aspects of coffee handling, but the agreement is made between roaster and farm directly. Sebastian Simsch, founder of Seattle Coffee Works, points out three key aspects of direct trade:
Almost all of the roasters with whom we work regularly spend their time visiting their partners in coffee-growing countries like Guatemala and Ethiopia. Their direct trade efforts allow them to work directly with growers to make the best coffee possible.
If you want the best cup of coffee, look for small-batch roasters who take pride in directly sourcing their coffee. While fair trade coffee labels are a great place to start in the supermarket, if you want the highest quality coffee—behind whose genesis the grower is assured fair economic standing—look for small roasters who work with growers on a direct trade basis.